The Chicago Cubs are entering the offseason with a major decision looming over them. The question at hand is whether star outfielder Cody Bellinger will remain with the team under his $27.5 million contract for the 2025 season, or if he will opt out to explore free agency.
As of now, it’s unclear which path Bellinger will take, with both options appearing equally viable. If he decides to leave, the Cubs will need to act swiftly to find a suitable replacement, as Bellinger has been a key contributor to the team’s offensive output over the past few seasons. His departure would significantly impact the lineup. Fans will soon learn of his decision as the offseason approaches.
Given this uncertainty, let’s explore four potential replacements the Cubs could consider if Bellinger opts to test the free agent waters.
One option could be Brent Rooker, whom the Cubs might target via trade with the Oakland Athletics. Rooker had an impressive 2024 season, playing 145 games and hitting 39 home runs with 112 RBIs while boasting a .293/.365/.562 batting line. At 29 years old, trading for Rooker would not only provide an immediate boost but also secure a valuable asset for the future due to his contract control.
Another strong candidate is Anthony Santander, who would be a significant target in free agency if Bellinger departs. Although he may not come cheap, Santander offers a powerful bat, having hit 44 home runs and driven in 102 runs while posting a .235/.308/.506 slash line. While his overall numbers may not be elite, he could quickly fill the power void left by Bellinger.
The Cubs might also consider Joc Pederson as a more affordable free agency option. Having played half of the 2021 season with Chicago, Pederson enjoyed a solid 2024 campaign, hitting 23 home runs and driving in 64 RBIs with a .275/.393/.515 slash line. While he may not be a direct elite replacement for Bellinger, he could still make a meaningful impact at a fraction of the cost compared to other top-tier outfielders.
Lastly, the Cubs could pursue a trade for Luis Robert Jr. from the Chicago White Sox, despite the challenges that come with trading within the division. At 27 years old, Robert represents a long-term investment. Though he struggled in 2024, hitting 14 home runs with 35 RBIs in 100 games, he showcased his potential in 2023 with 38 home runs and 80 RBIs. If the Cubs are looking to make a blockbuster move to replace Bellinger, Robert would be an intriguing option.