As Rodney Thomas II enters his third season in the NFL, the Indianapolis Colts safety finds himself at a pivotal juncture in his career. After emerging as an unexpected starter during his rookie season, the former seventh-round pick has struggled to replicate that success.

Thomas’ promising start saw him earn a significant role, but since then, his performance has waned, and he has lost his starting job to fellow third-year safety Nick Cross. This downward trend has raised concerns about his future with the team.

David Kenyon of Bleacher Report has expressed skepticism about Thomas’ ability to rebound, labeling him the team’s biggest potential bust for the 2024 season. Kenyon highlighted Indianapolis’ strong front seven but pointed to potential issues at safety. He noted that Cross had stepped in for Thomas late in the 2023 season, sparking a competition for the starting spot this year.

Kenyon’s assessment of Thomas’ performance last season is worrying. Thomas was not a reliable tackler and failed to make significant plays in coverage. These shortcomings raise doubts about his ability to perform at a high level this season.

During the 2023 season, Thomas made 15 starts, recording two interceptions, four passes defensed, and 34 tackles (30 solo). However, Pro Football Focus reported that Thomas allowed a 97.9 passer rating on 20 targets, indicating his struggles in pass coverage.

The Colts’ safety position is a focal point this offseason, with an intriguing battle unfolding. Julian Blackmon’s return on a one-year deal adds another layer of competition, with Thomas and Cross vying for the other starting role. As training camp begins, Cross appears to have the upper hand, given both players’ trajectories.

For Thomas, the 2024 season is critical. He needs to demonstrate improvement and consistency to secure his place on the team. Whether he can rise to the challenge remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: this season will be a defining moment in Rodney Thomas II’s NFL career.