The Knicks offer a $72.5 million extension for Isaiah Hartenstein, a pivotal decision for their roster planning. Initially expected to play mop-up minutes in the 2023-24 season, Hartenstein seized the opportunity when Mitchell Robinson was injured, establishing himself as a key player.
Having played for five teams over six NBA seasons, Hartenstein appears to have found a home with a competitive New York Knicks franchise. The team, with its improving chemistry, aims to commit long-term to its core players. However, this plan could be jeopardized if another team offers Hartenstein a more lucrative contract.
In 2022, Hartenstein played all 82 games as a reliable backup, but he became a full-time starter this season following Robinson’s ankle injury. The 26-year-old was instrumental in revitalizing New York’s defense and enhancing the offense through his synergy with Jalen Brunson. With free agency approaching, Hartenstein has proven to be a vital asset, averaging a career-best 8.3 rebounds, including 3.3 offensive rebounds. He is a skilled distributor and screen-setter, versatile enough to handle both ends of pick-and-rolls. His performance has attracted interest from teams seeking to strengthen their center rotation.
Hartenstein’s exceptional two-way play makes him a hot commodity in unrestricted free agency. Despite the Knicks’ desire to retain him, they are constrained by their ability to match market offers. They hold his early bird rights, allowing them to re-sign him for a maximum of $16-17 million annually.
Losing Hartenstein without compensation would be a significant blow for the Knicks, with little benefit beyond avoiding the luxury tax. However, Hartenstein has expressed his contentment with the team, and the Knicks are likely to offer him what they can, given the lack of appealing alternatives. After dealing with numerous injuries, retaining Hartenstein as a reliable backup is a logical move. Reports indicate that the Knicks can offer Hartenstein a four-year, $72.5 million max contract extension. The challenge will be competing with higher offers from other teams.
Hartenstein’s compatibility with Jalen Brunson is evident, as he facilitates offensive space and contributes significantly to the team. He averaged 7.8 points and achieved career highs in several categories this season. While Hartenstein justifiably seeks a substantial pay raise, the Knicks must balance his signing with their broader offseason plans.