Once again, Jim Bowden’s trade proposal falls short of the mark. Instead of offering a solution that satisfies both fan bases, his idea to send Pete Alonso to the Seattle Mariners is met with skepticism. It’s puzzling that amidst the Mets’ decent performance on the field, the focus remains on potential mid-season dismantling. Fans are hoping the team maintains its momentum in the Wild Card race, despite potential challenges from the Atlanta Braves and Philadelphia Phillies.
Bowden’s trade suggestion involves trading Alonso for Ty France, which fails to resonate with most fans. The Mets already have viable options, with many favoring Mark Vientos for the first base position in 2025. France, while once an All-Star, lacks the power and consistency to replace Alonso convincingly. Moreover, his contract only offers one additional year of control compared to Alonso’s, making him an unattractive long-term option.
Emerson Hancock, the other player in the proposed trade, is marginally more appealing but still falls short of expectations. Despite being a recent high draft pick, his performance in the majors has been mediocre, with an unremarkable ERA and a lackluster minor league track record. Given Alonso’s current struggles, the Mets may be inclined to lower their asking price in trades, but Bowden’s proposal offers significantly less value than Alonso deserves.
Overall, this trade idea is underwhelming and unlikely to appease Mets fans or anyone seeking a reasonable exchange involving Alonso. Even those open to the idea of parting ways with Alonso would find this proposal disappointing. It serves as a reminder that while Bowden may have a knack for stirring trade discussions, his strategies might not always be in the best interest of the team.