Bryce Elder entered Saturday night’s game boasting a commendable 1.50 ERA in two starts since his promotion from AAA Gwinnett. However, facing off against the formidable billion-dollar Dodgers lineup presented a markedly tougher challenge compared to his previous outings against the Marlins and Guardians.
Following a swift first inning from both potent offenses, Los Angeles seized the initiative with a two-run homer from Max Muncy. Shohei Ohtani extended the lead with a homer of his own in the subsequent inning, and the game escalated in the fourth inning. The Dodgers’ third home run of the night catalyzed a four-run surge, all of which were attributed to Elder, who departed the inning after just one out.
Elder’s performance evoked memories of his struggles in the latter half of the previous season. With Tyler Glasnow pitching for the Dodgers, the faltering Braves offense found little traction, prompting calls for Elder’s demotion back to Gwinnett.
Admittedly, Elder lacks the overpowering arsenal to dominate hitters, relying heavily on pinpoint accuracy for effectiveness. Against a formidable lineup like the Dodgers, any lapse in location can yield unfavorable results, as evidenced in this game.
Yet, it’s worth acknowledging Elder’s track record of success across various levels of competition. Despite the criticism, the 24-year-old has already earned an All-Star nod and maintains a solid 3.76 career ERA. Such consistency and accomplishment warrant recognition.
While the Braves fanbase eagerly anticipates the arrival of promising prospects like AJ Smith-Shawver and Hurston Waldrep, it’s essential to temper expectations. Their potential notwithstanding, they are not immune to imperfections, and a baseball season is a marathon, not a sprint.
If the Braves opt to pivot towards younger talent sooner rather than later, it’s a decision that warrants consideration. However, it’s crucial to not exaggerate the criticism directed towards Elder. Many teams would welcome a pitcher of his caliber into their rotation, and his continued presence every five days bodes well for the Braves’ prospects moving forward.