On3’s rating system differs from its main competitors like 247Sports, Rivals, and ESPN, particularly in awarding the prestigious fifth star to elite recruits. Despite this, there’s widespread disappointment over Duke basketball’s Isaiah Evans not receiving a five-star designation in the final 2024 On3 150 rankings.
Despite his standout performances and resemblance to former Blue Devil Brandon Ingram, Evans was ranked at No. 25 overall, which is significantly lower than expected. Alongside Cooper Flagg, Evans is one of two future Blue Devils who played in the 2024 McDonald’s All-American Game. However, despite his impressive achievements, Evans failed to secure the fifth star.
The 6-foot-6, 170-pound Evans, known for his high-scoring abilities, led his North Meck (N.C.) team to dramatic upset wins en route to a state championship as a senior, further highlighting his talent and potential.
Despite not being recognized as a five-star recruit by On3, Evans’ ranking still positions him as a highly sought-after prospect for Duke basketball. Similarly, other promising recruits like Kon Knueppel and Patrick Ngongba II have also faced discrepancies in their rankings compared to other platforms.
Overall, while there may be disparities in rankings, Duke’s recruiting class remains strong, with high expectations for the upcoming season under Coach Jon Scheyer’s leadership.